Australia - Regulatory - Super Telco Regulator - Analysis


This report was archived in September 2007 and has not been updated since May 2005. The report reviews the underlying policy issues pertinent to the Inquiry that looks into the merger of the Australian Communications Authority (ACA) and the Australian Broadcasting Authority (ABA) aimed at establishing the Australian Communications and Media Authority (ACMA). The Telecommunications Act 1997 did not deliver the outcomes envisaged and as a result, a review needs to be carried out. Structural separation between infrastructure and services is certainly an important factor, as discussed in separate reports, and increased regulatory power is the other key ingredient. The super regulator models from the UK and USA can be used as a guide to develop our own model. As suggested in my 2005 submission to the government, a Senate Commission could be set up to investigate this further.

Table of Contents

  • 1. Synopsis
  • 2. Recommendations Senate Committee Report
  • 3. Introduction
  • 4. Government Policies need to be reviewed
    • 4.1 Regulations are based on government policies
    • 4.2 Different regulatory models – same outcome
    • 4.3 Monopolies to remain in place for the next decade
  • 5. ACMA issues
    • 5.1 Current regulatory regime is not focused
    • 5.2 Self-regulatory regime only works for technical issues
    • 5.3 Self-regulatory regime doesn’t work for commercial and political issues
  • 6. Recommendations
    • 6.1 Policy review is needed
    • 6.2 Structural separation is already taking place
    • 6.3 Super regulator is the only way forward
    • 6.4 ACMA is a totally inappropriate regulatory structure
    • 6.5 A powerful regulator needed to manage a powerful industry
    • 6.6 We need to have the political will to make changes
    • 6.7 Establish a committee to investigate a super regulator
  • 7. Related reports
  • Exhibit 1 - ACMA recommendations
  • Exhibit 2 - Structural separation
  • Exhibit 3 – APEC calls for empowered regulators

Related Reports

Purchase this Report


Licence Information

Focus Report Profile


Regulations & Government Policies
Strategies & Analyses (Industry & Markets)

Number of pages 10

Status Archived

Last updated 28 May 2005
Update History

Analyst: Henry Lancaster

Share this Report

Purchase with Confidence

Paul, May I congratulate you on a very successful and enjoyable afternoon with the Minister. In providing the roundtable discussions between government and industry, it highlighted the strong interest by stakeholders in Broadband and its implementation but it also presented us with other issues and opportunities that we need to address.

Dominic Schipano, CITT

Special Offers

Caribbean - Telecoms, Mobile, and Broadband - Statistics and Analyses
US$795.00 until 30 Oct 2019
(normal price US$1,590.00)

Venezuela - Telecoms, Mobile and Broadband - Statistics and Analyses
US$575.00 until 30 Oct 2019
(normal price US$1,150.00)

Sample Reports

A selection of downloadable samples from our Annual Publications catalogue.

Download a Sample Report

More than 4,000 customers from 140 countries utilise BuddeComm Research

Are you interested in BuddeComm's Custom Research Service?

News & Views

Have the latest telecommunications industry news delivered to your inbox by subscribing to Paul's FREE weekly News & Views.